Choosing between a tub and a walk-in shower is usually the biggest decision in a bathroom renovation in Newmarket. It changes the price, the timeline, how the room feels every morning, and how well it suits everyone who lives in the house. Whether your home is in Glenway, Summerhill Estates, Stonehaven, Woodland Hill, Bristol-London, Gorham-College Manor or Armitage, this guide compares both options side by side so you can walk into a quote knowing what you want.

Nehan Construction is run by Yama Nehan, a licensed contractor with about 20 years of hands-on construction experience and a construction engineering degree from George Brown (Building Renovations). Yama also has about 15 years of home inspection experience and is among the top inspectors in Ontario, so we look closely at what sits behind the tiles: subfloor condition, signs of past leaks, drain locations and ventilation, before we recommend a tub or a shower.

Key Takeaways

  • A full 3-piece bathroom renovation with a tub is typically around $9,995 including labour and materials, plus HST.
  • A full 3-piece bathroom renovation with a stand-up (walk-in) shower is typically around $13,995 including labour and materials, plus HST.
  • A simple tub bathroom renovation takes about a week (around 7 business days).
  • Keep at least one tub in the house if you bathe young children or think about resale to families.
  • Upgrades and extra items raise the price; the final price is confirmed after a free site visit.

Tub or walk-in shower: which is right for a Newmarket bathroom?

Pick a tub if you bathe small children or pets, like to soak, or this is the only full bathroom in the house. Pick a walk-in shower if the people using the room want an easier step-in, more elbow room while showering, and a cleaner, more open look, and there is another tub elsewhere in the home. Many Newmarket families keep the tub in the main bathroom and put a walk-in shower in the ensuite.

How do a tub bathroom and a walk-in shower bathroom compare?

Factor 3-piece with tub 3-piece with walk-in shower
Typical price Around $9,995 including labour and materials, plus HST Around $13,995 including labour and materials, plus HST
Typical timeline About a week (around 7 business days) for a simple renovation Depends on the shower size, tile and glass; confirmed in your quote
Best for Families with young kids, soaking, the only full bath in the home Adults, easier step-in, ensuites, a more open feel
Everyday cleaning Tub surround and tub; fewer glass surfaces Glass panel or door to wipe; fewer corners if tiled simply
Why the price differs Standard tub and surround install More tile work, a shower base or tiled floor, waterproofing and glass

Both prices are base figures. Real quotes come in higher only when you add upgrades or extra items, such as larger tile, a niche, a bench, a rain head, a double vanity or heated floors. For a deeper look at the shower option, see what a walk-in shower bathroom renovation costs in Ontario.

Why does a walk-in shower cost more than a tub?

A tub arrives as one finished piece. A walk-in shower is built in place: more wall and floor area is tiled, the shower floor has to slope properly to the drain, the whole wet area needs a careful waterproofing layer behind the tile, and a glass panel or door is measured and installed at the end. That extra labour and material is the main reason for the gap between the two base prices.

Checklist: questions to answer before you decide

  • Is this the only bathroom in the house with a tub?
  • Who uses the room every day, and does anyone need an easier step-in?
  • Do you actually take baths, or does the tub only get used as a shower?
  • How much time can the household manage without this bathroom?
  • Are there signs of past leaks, soft floor spots or a musty smell we should look at during the visit?
  • Which upgrades matter to you, and which can wait?

What happens during a bathroom renovation with Nehan Construction?

  1. Free site visit. We look at the room, the floor and the plumbing layout, and talk through tub versus shower.
  2. Written, itemized quote. You see what is included and what any upgrades add.
  3. Demolition and prep. Old fixtures and finishes come out, and we check the floor and walls once they are open.
  4. Rough work. Licensed plumbing and electrical subcontractors handle drain, supply, lighting and fan work when the scope calls for it.
  5. Waterproofing, tile and fixtures. The tub or shower, tile, vanity, toilet and accessories go in.
  6. Final walk-through. We go over the finished room with you before we call it done.

Why Newmarket homeowners choose Nehan Construction

We are a licensed contractor with low overhead, so pricing stays fair and quotes spell out what is included. We are fully insured, work with licensed electrical, plumbing and HVAC subcontractors, and bring a home inspector’s eye for quality control to every bathroom. We serve Newmarket, the rest of York Region, the GTA and Hamilton. See our bathroom renovation services or learn more about Yama and Nehan Construction. If your bathroom is in the basement, our basement flood protection page covers backwater valves, sump pumps and waterproofing.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a bathroom renovation cost in Newmarket?

A full 3-piece bathroom renovation with a tub is typically around $9,995 including labour and materials, and one with a stand-up (walk-in) shower is typically around $13,995 including labour and materials, both plus HST. Upgrades raise the price, and the final price is confirmed after a free site visit.

How long does a tub bathroom renovation take?

A simple tub bathroom renovation takes about a week, around 7 business days. Walk-in shower timelines depend on size, tile and glass, and you get a realistic timeline with your written quote.

Should I remove my only bathtub?

Usually not. If you bathe young children, like to soak, or may sell to a family later, keep at least one tub in the house and put the walk-in shower in a second bathroom or ensuite.

Can you replace a tub with a walk-in shower in the same space?

In most bathrooms, yes. A standard tub alcove can often become a walk-in shower. We confirm drain location and floor condition during the free site visit.

Do you renovate bathrooms across Newmarket?

Yes. Nehan Construction renovates bathrooms across Newmarket, including Glenway, Summerhill Estates, Stonehaven, Woodland Hill, Bristol-London, Gorham-College Manor and Armitage, along with the rest of the GTA and Hamilton.

Book a free bathroom renovation visit in Newmarket

Not sure whether to keep the tub? Talk it through with a licensed contractor. Call or text 647-704-7100, email nehanconstruction@gmail.com, or request a free estimate online.